My expeirence with Gina held companies, is she is ruthless in the short term. But in the long term, it generally always works out. Unless she manages to take the company private (then you lose the long term benefits).
I think what they do, is they buy into a company with a long term view. Then they leave the shares with their custodian...who can lend them out to shorters. This gives Gina some income in the short term. And she doesn't care if the share price is pushed down. Hell, if it is pushed down even more, she could buy even more.
Lots of heat has come out of the rare earth market globally. Becasue Trump said it is all fixed.
But - people in the know....know this is not the case. It has just kicked the can down the road. At REEx we are hearing that there will be a big crunch around mid 2026. Unless China actually starts delivering what they promised....which is highly unlikely.
But even if that happens, the world needs more RE and in needs to create an ex-China supply. Long term most of the top RE companies should do very well.
All just my humble opinions.